How it worksPricingCheck your roadGuidesFAQ
ContactLog inStart a claim
Home/Guides/Section 41 explained

Guide · Your rights

Section 41 of the Highways Act explained

The short answer

Section 41 of the Highways Act 1980 puts a duty on the highway authority to maintain public roads in England and Wales. If a road is in a dangerous condition because of a failure to maintain it, and that causes damage, the authority can be liable. Section 58 then gives it a defence if it took reasonable care, so most claims turn on both sections together.

Last reviewed 22 November 2026

A deep pothole in a tarmac road

Across the UK

What Section 41 says

Section 41 says that the authority responsible for a highway maintainable at public expense is under a duty to maintain it. The courts have long read "maintain" to include repair: keeping the road in a condition that is reasonably safe for the traffic that would be expected to use it.

Since 2003, Section 41 also says the authority must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that safe passage along a highway is not endangered by snow or ice.

What a claimant has to show

To succeed under Section 41, a claimant generally has to show:

  1. The road is a highway maintainable at public expense (most public roads are)
  2. It was dangerous: not just imperfect, but a real danger to ordinary users
  3. The danger came from a failure to maintain or repair it
  4. That danger caused the damage

Courts don't expect roads to be perfect. A minor dip or uneven surface isn't enough. A pothole with a deep, sharp edge often is.

Where Section 58 comes in

Even if the road was dangerous, Section 58 lets the authority escape liability by proving it took such care as was reasonably required to secure that the road was not dangerous. The Act lists the things a court considers, including the character of the road and the traffic on it, the standard of maintenance appropriate, the state of repair a reasonable person would expect, whether the authority knew or could reasonably have known of the defect, and any warning notices.

In practice, the authority points to its inspection system: how often it inspects the road, and its records showing it did. That is why the inspection records decide so many claims.

Scotland and Northern Ireland

Section 41 applies in England and Wales. Scotland's roads duty comes from the Roads (Scotland) Act 1984 and Northern Ireland's from the Roads (Northern Ireland) Order 1993. The questions are similar: was the road dangerous, and did the authority take reasonable care? See our pages on Scotland and Northern Ireland.

  1. 01What Section 41 says
  2. 02What a claimant has to show
  3. 03Where Section 58 comes in
  4. 04Scotland and Northern Ireland

On this page

  1. What Section 41 says
  2. What a claimant has to show
  3. Where Section 58 comes in
  4. Scotland and Northern Ireland

0% read

Hit a pothole?

We’ll handle the claim for one fixed fee. You keep 100% of the payout.

Start a claim

Common questions

What is the difference between Section 41 and Section 58?

Section 41 creates the authority's duty to maintain the road. Section 58 gives it a defence if it took reasonable care, usually by showing a proper system of inspection and repair.

Does Section 41 cover pavements?

Yes. Section 41 covers highways maintainable at public expense, which includes most footways as well as roads.

More answers in our full FAQ.

Start a claim

Rather we handled it?

We find the right authority, request their inspection records and pursue the claim for you, all for one fixed fee.

Start a claim

Keep reading

Related guides

All guides
  • Guide · Process01FOI requests for pothole inspection records, with a templateHow to request a council's pothole inspection, defect and repair records under Freedom of Information or the Environmental Information Regulations, with a template and what to do if it's refused.Read more
  • Claim rejected02Council rejected your pothole claim? What to do nextWhy councils reject pothole damage claims, how the Section 58 defence works, how to test it with inspection records, and the options for challenging a refusal or going to court.Read more
  • Guide · Process03Letter before action for a pothole claimWhat a letter before action is, when to send one to a council or road authority after a refused pothole claim, what it must contain, and what happens next.Read more
  • England04Pothole damage claims in EnglandHow pothole claims work in England: county, unitary, metropolitan and London councils, National Highways and TfL, how to tell who runs the road, and links to every council page.Read more

Vehicle damage claims against highway authorities, pursued on your behalf for a single fixed fee.

hello@pothole-claim.co.ukSend a message

Contents

  • How it works
  • Pricing
  • Check your road
  • Guides
  • FAQ
  • Contact

Help

  • Pothole compensation
  • Rejected claims
  • Evidence checklist
  • Time limits
  • Letter before action
  • About us

Roads

  • Pothole claims in Scotland
  • Pothole claims in Northern Ireland
  • National Highways claims
  • TfL claims
  • Pothole claims in England
  • Pothole claims in Wales
  • Councils

Claims

  • Tyre damage claims
  • Alloy wheel claims
  • Suspension damage claims
  • Motorcycle claims
  • Cycle claims
  • Company and lease cars

Pothole Claim

© 2026 Pothole Claim

  • Terms of service
  • Privacy policy
  • Refund policy
  • Cookie policy
Crafted by Niddo(opens in a new tab)

You can claim directly from the highway authority yourself at no cost. Pothole Claim is not a law firm and is not authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority.