Why the records matter
In England and Wales most refusals rely on Section 58 of the Highways Act 1980: the authority says it had a reasonable system of inspection and repair. The only way to test that is with its own documents.
What to ask for
Name the road, the stretch (between which junctions or house numbers), and the date of your incident. Ask for:
- The inspection policy or highway safety inspection manual in force at the time, including inspection frequencies and intervention levels for that road
- The inspection records for that stretch for the 12 months before the incident
- Any reports or complaints from the public about defects on that stretch in the same period
- The defect and repair records, including when each defect was logged, its category, its target repair time and when it was repaired
A template
Dear Information Officer,
Under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and the Environmental Information Regulations 2004, please provide the following for [road name], between [junction or house number] and [junction or house number], [town]:
- The highway inspection policy in force on [date], including the inspection frequency and the intervention levels for carriageway defects that applied to this road.
- Records of all safety inspections of this stretch between [date 12 months earlier] and [date].
- All reports or complaints of defects on this stretch received in the same period, with the date received.
- All defect and repair records for this stretch in the same period, showing the date each defect was recorded, its category or priority, its target repair time and the date it was repaired.
I would prefer to receive the information electronically.
Yours faithfully,
[Your name]
In Scotland, refer to the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 and the Environmental Information (Scotland) Regulations 2004 instead.
Deadlines and refusals
- 20 working days is the normal deadline. EIR allows an extension to 40 working days for complex requests.
- Cost limits: under FOI an authority can refuse a request that would cost too much to answer. Narrow it (a shorter stretch or period) and ask again.
- If it refuses or doesn't reply, ask for an internal review, then complain to the Information Commissioner's Office (in Scotland, the Scottish Information Commissioner).
Reading the records
Look for inspections that were late or missed against the policy, a defect that was recorded and left, a public report before your incident, or a repair that took longer than the target time. Any of these can undermine the defence. See what to do if your claim is rejected.

