Claim rejected

Council rejected your pothole claim? What to do next

The short answer

A refusal is often not the end. Most rejections rely on the authority saying it inspected the road properly, which in England and Wales is the Section 58 defence. You can test that with the authority's own inspection and repair records, challenge the decision in writing, and if needed take the claim to the small claims court.

Last reviewed

A deep pothole in a tarmac road

Across the UK

Why claims get rejected

Highway authorities have a legal duty to maintain the roads they are responsible for. But the law also lets them escape liability if they took reasonable care. In England and Wales this is Section 58 of the Highways Act 1980. A typical refusal letter says something like: the road was inspected on a set date, no defect needing repair was found, and so the authority is not liable.

Other common reasons:

  • Wrong authority. The road belongs to someone else (for example, National Highways rather than the council).
  • Below the intervention level. The authority says the pothole was not deep enough to need repair under its policy.
  • Not enough evidence of the location, the damage or the cost.
  • Already repaired. The authority says it fixed the defect within its target time.

How to test a Section 58 defence

The defence stands or falls on documents. Ask for:

  1. The inspection policy for that class of road: how often it should be inspected and what depth of defect triggers a repair.
  2. The inspection records for the 12 months before your incident.
  3. Any reports or complaints about that defect from the public.
  4. The repair records, showing when the pothole was logged and fixed.

Things that weaken the defence:

  • Inspections that were missed or late against the authority's own schedule
  • A defect reported by the public and not repaired within the target time
  • A defect recorded at an inspection but left unrepaired
  • A policy that departs from national guidance without good reason

Challenge the decision in writing

If the records show a gap, write back to the claims team. Quote the policy and the records, explain why the defence does not apply, and ask them to reconsider. Keep it factual and keep copies.

Going to court

If the authority still refuses, you can take the claim to court. In England and Wales, claims up to £10,000 normally go through the small claims track of the County Court, where you do not need a solicitor and costs are limited. Send a letter before action first. Scotland uses simple procedure in the sheriff court, and Northern Ireland has its own small claims procedure in the county court.

Time limits

For vehicle damage, the usual limit is six years from the incident in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and five years in Scotland. In practice, act much sooner: records are easier to obtain and the details are fresh.

How we help

If your claim has been refused, start a claim with us and tell us it was rejected. We review the refusal, request the records the authority relied on, and challenge the decision if the evidence supports it.

Common questions

Can I appeal a rejected pothole claim?

There is no formal appeal body, but you can ask the authority to reconsider in writing, with evidence. If it still refuses, you can take the claim to the small claims court (simple procedure in Scotland).

The council says the pothole was too shallow. Is that the end?

Not necessarily. Intervention depths are set by each authority's own risk-based policy, often around 40mm on roads. Check what depth applies, whether the pothole was measured, and whether other factors (such as an edge or a cluster of defects) made it dangerous.

How long do I have to challenge a refusal?

There is no fixed deadline for asking the authority to reconsider, but the legal time limit for court action is usually six years from the incident (five in Scotland).

More answers in our full FAQ.

Start a claim

Rather we handled it?

We find the right authority, request their inspection records and pursue the claim for you, all for one fixed fee.

Start a claim