Side by side
| Claim from the authority | Claim on your insurance | |
|---|---|---|
| Excess | None | You pay it |
| No-claims discount | Not affected | May be affected, unless protected |
| Future premiums | Not affected | Often rise after a claim |
| Speed of repair | You pay first and claim back | Insurer may arrange repair quickly |
| Chance of payment | Depends on the authority's records | Usually paid if covered |
| Who chases the authority | You, or us | Your insurer may, to recover its costs |
When the authority is the better route
- The damage is a tyre, a wheel, tracking or suspension, typically a few hundred pounds, often close to or below your excess
- You want to protect your no-claims discount
- The records suggest the authority should have found and fixed the pothole
When insurance might make sense
- The damage is very large, such as after a crash caused by a pothole
- You cannot afford to pay for the repair first
- The authority's liability looks weak, for example a brand new pothole on a road inspected the day before
Can I do both?
You can claim from the authority for your uninsured losses, such as your excess, even if your insurer paid for the repair. Your insurer may pursue the authority for its own outlay. Tell both sides, so nothing is claimed twice.
Does an authority claim count as an accident?
Not as an insurance claim. You may still need to tell your insurer about an incident under your policy terms, especially if the car was damaged in a collision. Check your policy.

