Section 58 explained: why councils reject pothole claims (and what you can do)
Most pothole claims are rejected using the Section 58 defence. What it means, how councils use it, and how inspection records can turn a ‘no’ into a ‘yes’.
The Pothole Claims team2 min read

If you’ve claimed for pothole damage and been turned down, there’s a good chance the letter mentioned Section 58. It’s the most common reason pothole claims are rejected, and one of the most misunderstood.
The duty to maintain the road
Under Section 41 of the Highways Act 1980, highway authorities in England and Wales have a duty to maintain the roads they’re responsible for. If a road isn’t kept in a reasonable state of repair and that causes damage, the authority can be liable.
The defence: “we took reasonable care”
Section 58 of the same Act gives authorities a defence. They aren’t liable if they can show they took such care as was reasonably required to make sure that part of the road wasn’t dangerous to traffic.
In practice, they usually point to their inspection regime: a schedule for how often each road is inspected, and how quickly defects of different sizes must be repaired. Most authorities base this on the national code of practice, Well-managed Highway Infrastructure, which encourages a risk-based approach, where busy roads are inspected more often than quiet lanes.
So a typical rejection says, in effect: we inspected this road when our policy said we should, and the pothole wasn’t there (or wasn’t bad enough to repair) at the time.
Why that isn’t always the end of it
The defence only works if the authority actually followed a reasonable system. That’s why the most useful evidence in a pothole claim is often the authority’s own paperwork:
- Inspection records: were inspections carried out on the dates the policy required?
- Defect and repair records: had this pothole been spotted or reported before? Was it repaired within the authority’s own timescale?
- Public reports: had anyone reported it, and what happened next?
- The inspection policy itself: is the frequency reasonable for a road like this one?
If an inspection was missed, a defect was logged but not fixed in time, or the policy wasn’t followed, the Section 58 defence can fall away.
How to get the records
You can ask the authority directly for the inspection and repair history for the stretch of road, and many claimants use a Freedom of Information request to do it. Be specific: give the road, the exact location and a date range (for example, the 12 months before your incident).
What this means for your claim
- Don’t be put off by a first rejection. It’s common.
- Ask for the records before you accept the decision.
- Compare what happened with what the authority’s own policy says should have happened.
Requesting and reviewing inspection records is a standard part of every claim we handle. If you’d rather we dealt with it, start your claim and we’ll take it from there.
This article is general information, not legal advice.

Start a claim
Rather we handled it?
We find the right authority, request their inspection records and fight the claim for you, all for one fixed fee.
Keep reading


